MICHIGAN REPORTS

CASES DECIDED

IN TAS

SUPREME COURT

MICHIGAN

FROM

JULY 2 TO OCTOBER 22, 1895

JOHN A. BROOKS

STATE REPORTER

VOL. 106

FIRST EDITION

CHICAGO
CALLAGHAN & CO.

SUPREME COURT RULE 65

Adopted May 19, 1897.

Causes where the record fails to show that the amount involved,
exclusive of costs, is more than five hundred dollars, and all motions,
shall be submitted on briefs, unless otherwise ordered by the court.
To take effect June 1, 1897.

Acc Aug 26, 1897

Copyright, 1897, for the State of Michigan, by Washington Gardner,

Secretary of State.

CHARLES D. LONG, FLINT, . . . . .
CLAUDIUS B. GRANT, MARQUETTE, . . .
ROBERT M. MONTGOMERY, GRAND RAPIDS, .
FRANK A, HOOKER, CHARLOTTE, . .

Dec. 31, 1897
Dec. 31, 1899
Dec. 31, 1901
Dec. 31, 1908

CLERK-CHARLES C. HOPKINS, LANSING,
CRIER-MOSES R. TAYLOR, LANSING,

ATTORNEY GENERAL-FRED A. MAYNARD, GRAND RAPIDS.

Pursuant to Act No. 182, Pub. Acts 1893, the Justicos reside at Lansing during their terms of office.

CIRCUIT JUDGES.

2.

៩៨១ ៩៨

VICTOR H. LANE,

ADRIAN.
ORVILLE W. COOLIDGE,. . . . . NILES.
ROBERT E. FRAZER,
GEORGE S. HOSMER.
WILLIAM L. CARPENTER,

DETROIT.
WILLARD M. LILLIBRIDGE,
JOSEPH W. DONOVAN,
ERASTUS PECK, . . . . . . . .

JACKSON.
CLEMENT SMITH,. . . . . · · ·

HASTINGS.
JOSEPH B. MOORE, . . . . . . . LAPEER.
CHARLES H. WISNER, . . . . . . FLINT.
FRANK D. M. DAVIS, .

IONIA.
GEORGE M. BUCK, ..

KALAMAZOO.
( ROBERT B. McKNIGHT,'
{ WILLIAM R. KENDRICK, . .. SAGINAW.
(EUGENE WILBER,
JOSEPH H. STEERE,

SAULT STE. MARIE.
JAY A. HUBBELL, .. · · · · · · HOUGHTON.
ROSCOE L. CORBETT, ..

TRAVERSE CITY.
FRED J. RUSSELL, . . . . . . .

HART.
GEORGE L. YAPLE, . . .

MENDON.
JAMES B. ELDREDGE, . . . . . . Mt. CLEMENS.
I WILLIAM E. GROVE,
7 ALLEN C. ADSIT,

....GRAND RAPIDS,

. . . .
'ANDREW C. MAXWELL, . . . . . BAY CITY.
JAMES B. MCMAHON, ..

LUDINGTON.
PHILIP PADGHAM, . . . . . . . ALLEGAN.
PETER F. DODDS, . . . . .

MT. PLEASANT,
EDWARD D. KINNE, ..

ANN ARBOR.
WILLIAM H. SIMPSON, ... AU SABLE.
WATSON BEACH, .

LEXINGTON,
JOHN W. STONE, . . . . .

MARQUETTE.
ROBERT J. KELLEY,

ALPENA.
JOHN H. PALMER, ...

BIG RAPIDS.
FRED H. ALDRICH, .

CADILLAC.
SHERMAN B. DABOLL,

ST. JOHNS.
ROLLIN H. PERSON,

LANSING.
SAMUEL W. VANCE, .

PORT HURON,
NORMAN W. HAIRE,

IRONWOOD.
OSCAR ADAMS, ..

CHEBOYGAN.

WEST BRANCH.
(LUKE S. MONTAGUE,

HOWELL.
STEARNS F. SMITH. . .. ., Owosso.

SC

KARTI,

.

.

.

.

.

.

Resigned September 16, 1895. * Appointed to fill vacancy. • Died September 28, 1895. * Appointed to fill vacancy October 4, 1896.

JUDICIAL CIRCUITS.

Circuits.

Circuits