Page images
PDF
EPUB

In 1 vol. large 8vo., 348., the Second Edition of

NIVERSAL LIFE ASSURANCE

21

SOCIETY,

WRONGS AND THEIR REMEDIES: being UNI, King William street, London, E.C. Established 19834, with

a Treatise on the Law of Torts. By C. G. ADDISON, Esq. Barrister at Law, Author of "The Law of Contracts."

London Stevens, Sons, & Haynes, Bell-yard, Lincoln's-inn.

Now ready, in royal 12mo., price 168. 6d. cloth,

Branches at Calcutta, Madras, and Bombay.-Very economical Home and Colonial Rates for Civil and Military Lives. Division every Year of one-fifth of Profits. Premiums on all Participating Policies Six Years in force reduced one-half for the Year ending May, 1865, so that 50%. only of each 1001. of premium falling due is charged. Total Assurances issued exceed 7,000,0007. sterling; Claims paid, 1,250,000l.; Cash Bo

THE PRACTICE in LUNACY. Fourth Edition, nuses to Assured, 565,000%., or an average annual return of 98. in the

FREDERICK HENDRIKS, Actuary and Secretary.

Committees, Forms, Costs, the Statutes, General Orders, and copious terests, and on Real and other Property in connexion with Assurances. Index, adapted to the Provisions of "The Lunacy Regulation Acts, 1853 and 1862." By JOSEPH ELMER, of the Office of the Masters in Lunacy.

Stevens, Sons, & Haynes, 26, Bell-yard.

[blocks in formation]

RUSSELL ON ARBITRATION.-Third Edition.

In royal Svo., price 36s. cloth,

LAW

ANNUITIES AND REVERSIONS.

AW REVERSIONARY INTEREST SOCIETY. 68, CHANCERY-LANE, LONDON. CHAIRMAN-Russell Gurney, Q.C., Recorder of London. DEPUTY CHAIRMAN-Sir W. J. Alexander, Bart, Q. C. Reversions and Life Interests purchased. Immediate and Deferred Annuities granted in exchange for Reversionary and Contingent In

terests.

Loans may also be obtained on the security of Reversions. Annuities, Immediate, Deferred, and Contingent, and also Endowments, granted on favourable terms.

Prospectuses and Forms of Proposal, and all further information, may be had at the Office. C. B. CLABON, Sec.

COALS.-J. PERCIVAL & CO.'S, BEST ONLY,

screened, Cash Price 28s. per Ton.-HORSESHOE WHARF, UPPER THAMES-STREET. West-end Office, 64, New Bond-street.

A TREATISE on the POWER and DUTY of an DEBENTURES at 5, 5, and 6 per CENT.

[blocks in formation]
[blocks in formation]

Her in the Reigns of William IV and Queen Victoria; including

Prescription, Limitations of Actions, Abolition of Fines, &c.; Payment of Debts, Wills, Judgments, &c.; the Trustee Acts, Leases and Sales of Settled Estates, the Property and Trustees Amendment Acts, and Trustees and Mortgagees Clauses, &c. With copious Notes and Forms of Deeds. Corrected and enlarged, with New Cases and Statutes. By LEONARD SHELFORD, Esq., Barrister at Law. The Seventh Edition, with many Alterations and Additions. In 1 thick vol. 8vo.

H. Sweet; W. Maxwell; Stevens, Sons, & Haynes.

[blocks in formation]

R. HODGSON will SELL by AUCTION, at his Rooms, 115, Chancery-lane, W. C., on FRIDAY, Jan. 27, at lo'clock punctually (by order of the Executors), the valuable LAW LIBRARY of the late RICHARD OGLE, Esq., Barrister at Law, of the Inner Temple; comprising the Year-Books; Ruffhead's Statutes at Large; a Series of the Law Journal; Harrison's and Fisher's Digests; Bacon's and Viner's Abridgments; Reeve's History of the English Law; a good selection of useful Practical Works in the various branches of the Law; and a Series of the Common Law and Equity Reports, House of Lords and Privy Council Cases, &c.; all in good condition. To be viewed, and Catalogues had.

[blocks in formation]

CURES OF ASTHMA AND COUGHS, BY - From R. LOCOCK'S PULMONIC WAFERS.Mr. LEITH, Chemist, 95, Baker-street, Stirling:-"I find your Wafers give great satisfaction, and I can recommend them with greater faith than ever." They give instant relief, and a rapid cure of asthraa, consumption, coughs, colds, and all disorders of the throat and lungs. They have a pleasant taste. 18. 1d., 28. 9d., and 4s. Cd. per box, by all Druggists.

[blocks in formation]

THE PROFESSION MAY SAVE SIX SHIL

LINGS IN THE POUND by purchasing their OFFICE PAPERS at
PARTRIDGE & COZEN S,

WHOLESALE STATIONERS, ACCOUNT BOOK MAKERS, and
DEALERS in PARCHMENT,

192, Fleet street, corner of Chancery-lane, London, E. C. Carriage paid to the Country on Orders exceeding 20s. PARTRIDGE & COZENS, as well as being bonâ fide Manufacturers of many of the best qualities of Writing Papers, are the Sole Agents in London for some of the Largest Paper Makers in the Kingdom, therefore beg to impress upon their patrons the advantages they are enabled to offer them (unattainable by other houses), viz. supplying the public with "papers direct from the mills" at one profit only-being at least 30 per cent. under the usual RETAIL charges-as the intermediate profit is saved to the purchaser.

Draft Paper, 68., 7s., 78. 9d., and 9s. per ream.
Brief Paper, 13s. 6d., 16s., and 18s. 6d. per ream.
Foolscap Paper, 10s. 6d., 138. 6d., and 17s. 6d. per ream.
Cream Laid Note, 3s., 4s., and 5s. per ream.

Large Cream Laid Note, is., 6s., and 7s. 6d. per ream.
Large Blue Note, 3s., 4s., and 6s. per ream.

Envelopes, Cream, Blue, or Buff, 28. 9d., 3s. 6d., and 4s. 6d. per 1000.
Foolscap Official Envelopes, 18. 6d. per 100, or 138. 6d. per 1000.
Blottings, Browns, Cartridges, Tapes, Piercers, Runners, &c.

Letter Copying Press (warranted), 25s.; Good Stand for ditto, with two Drawers, 178.

Parchment, best Quality. Indenture Skins, Printed and Machine-ruled to hold twenty or thirty folios, 1s. 4d. each, or 15s. per dozen.

Seconds or Followers, Ruled, 1s. 3d. each, or 14s. per dozen. Records or Memorials, Ruled, 58. per dozen, or 22s. 6d. per roll. Ledgers, Day-books, Cash-books, Letter or Minute-books, an immense stock in various bindings. An Illustrated Price List of Inkstands; Postage Scales; Writing-cases; Despatch Boxes; Oak and Walnut Stationery Cabinets; and other useful articles adapted for Library or Office, post-free.

PARTRIDGE & COZENS, 192, Fleet-street, E. C.

Printed by HENRY HANSARD, at his Printing Office, in Parker Street, in the Parish of St. Giles-in-the-Fields, in the County of Middlesex; and published by HENRY SWEET, of No. 3, CHANCERY LANE, and RICHARD STEVENS, of No. 26, BELL YARD, LINCOLN'S INN, at the OFFICE, No. 39, BELL YARD, LINCOLN'S INN.-Saturday, January 21, 1865.

No. 525, NEW SERIES.-Vol. XI.

No. 1464, OLD SERIES.-Vol. XXIX.

JANUARY 28, 1865.

PRICE 1s., or with Digest Supplement, 2s.

Equity and Law Life Assurance Society,
Society,

18, LINCOLN'S-INN-FIELDS, LONDON, W.C.

CAPITAL-ONE million, fullY SUBSCRIBED.

DIRECTORS.

CHAIRMAN-GEORGE LAKE RUSSELL, Esq., Barrister at Law.

DEPUTY CHAIRMAN-JOHN MOXON CLABON, Esq., Solicitor (Fearon, Clabon, & Fearon).

JOHN EDWARD ARMSTRONG, Esq.. Barrister at Law.
HENRY WM. BIRCH, Esq., Solicitor (Birch & Ingram).
HENRY FOX BRISTOWE, Esq., Barrister at Law.

R. J. P. BROUGHTON, Esq., Solicitor (White, Broughton, & White).
ANTHONY CLEASBY, Esq., Q. C.

JOHN ELLIS CLOWES, Esq., Solicitor (Clowes & Hickley).
CHARLES J. DIMOND, Esq., Solicitor (Simpson & Dimond).
SIMON DUNNING, Esq., Solicitor (Burder & Dunning).

JOHN W. HAWKINS, Esq., Solicitor (Chief Clerk to the Master of
the Rolls).

WILLIAM E. HILLIARD, Esn., Gray's-inn.

N. HOLLINGSWORH, Esq., Solicitor (Hollingsworth, Tyerman, &
Green).

THOMAS HUGHES, Esq., Barrister at Law.

JOHN ILIFFE, Esq., Solicitor (Cardale, Iliffe, & Russell).
THOMAS GLOVER KENSIT, Esq., Clerk to Skinners' Company.
CHARLES HENRY MOORE, Esq., Solicitor, 7, Lincoln's-inn-fields.
EDMUND F. MOORE, Esq., Barrister at Law.

WM. BENFORD NELSON, Esq., Solicitor (Park & W. B. Nelson).
FREDERICK PEAKE. Esq, Solicitor (Barker, Bowker, & Peake).
SIR ROBBRT J. PHILLIMORE, Q. C., the Queen's Advocate.
GEORGE W. K. POTTER, Esq., Secondary of London.
W. B. S. RACKHAM, Esq., Solicitor, 46, Lincoln's-inn-fields.
GEORGE ROBINS, Esq., Solicitor (Warry, Robins, & Burges).
ALFRED H. SHADWELL, Esq., Taxing Master in Chancery.
RICHARD SMITH, Esq. Solicitor (Richd. & W. B. Smith).

Solicitor-GEOrge rooper, Esq., 26, Lincoln's-inn-fields.

NINE-TENTHS of the Total Profits are divided among the Assured. Considerably more than one-tenth of the Profits is derived from Policies which do not participate in the Profits, so that THE ASSURED HAVE LARGER BONUSES THAN IF THEY FORMED A MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY, and received the whole of the Profits derived from their own Policies.

The last BONUS averaged about SIXTY PER CENT. on the Premiums paid, and TWO PER CENT. PER ANNUM on the Sums assured. The EXPENSES of Management are less than FIVE PER CENT. on the Income.

The PREMIUMS are calculated for every half-year of age.

The Policies of this Society, in the hands of third parties, are not vitiated by SUICIDE, or by the Life assured proceeding beyond the limits allowed.

NOTICES of ASSIGNMENT of Policies registered and acknowledged free of charge. Printed Forms for such Notices furnished when required. The usual Commission allowed to Solicitors introducing Insurances, the Commission being continued to the person originally entitled to it as long as the Policy remains in force, through whatever channel the Premium may be paid.

LOANS granted on the Society's Policies, on Reversions, Life Interests, and other approved Security.

The Annual Reports and full Statements of Account are regularly printed, and may be obtained on application.

T. B. SPRAGUE, Actuary and Secretary.

LAW
AW EXAMINATIONS.-A Solicitor, recently THE PROFESSION MAY SAVE SIX SHIL-

admitted, and of small Practice, wishes to READ with Gentlemen going up for their Intermediate or Final Examination. Every care and attention will be bestowed on their studies. Address, Alpha, care of J. Thomas, Law Stationer, 15, Serle-street, Lincoln's-inn, W. C.

Now ready, price 10s. 6d., the Third Edition of the

COMMON LAW PROCEDURE. BY THOMAS

HUGH MARKHAM, Esq., M.A., Barrister at Law, Inner
Temple.
London: Stannard & Smith, 30, Chancery-lane.

This day is published, in 2 vols., Third Edition, 408. cloth, pp. 1732,

DEACON'S LAW AND PRACTICE OF BANK

RUPTCY. By A. G. LANGLEY, Esq., Barrister at Law. This work contains upwards of 4000 Cases, the Statutes, General Orders, Forms in Bankruptcy, and the County Court Bankruptcy Orders, 1863.

London: Shaw & Sons, Fetter-lane.

LAW DIGEST.

Now ready, price 17. 7s. 6d., OTANDA DIGEST for 1863 and 1864; with No! Synoptical Index. The Portion relating to Statutes, General Orders, &c., is arranged tabularly, by which all Decisions on Statutes, &c., can be seen at a glance. The Index to the General Law also affords a new and particularly ready access to all the Decisions thereon, with References to Leading Cases and Text Books. This Digest is kept up biennially, at an annual subscription of 15s.

T. F. A. Day, 13, Carey-street, Lincoln's-inn, W. C.

THE SOLICITORS' JOURNAL, the organ of the Legal Profession, every SATURDAY, price 6d. With the WEEKLY REPORTER, containing the Casca, when practicable, down to the prerious Wednesday, price 1s. Annual Subscription to both Publications, 52., which includes postage and double numbers, when paid in advance. Office, 59, Carey-street, W. C.

No. 525, VOL. X!, NEW SERIES.

LINGS IN THE POUND by purchasing their OFFICE PAPERS at PARTRIDGE & COZENS, WHOLESALE STATIONERS, ACCOUNT BOOK MAKERS, and DEALERS in PARCHMENT,

192, Fleet street, corner of Chancery-lane, London, E. C. Carriage paid to the Country on Orders exceeding 20s. PARTRIDGE & COZENS, as well as being bonâ fide Manufacturers of many of the best qualities of Writing Papers, are the Sole Agents in London for some of the Largest Paper Makers in the Kingdom, therefore beg to impress upon their patrons the advantages they are enabled to offer them (unattainable by other houses), viz. supplying the public with "papers direct from the mills" at one profit only-being at least 30 per cent. under the usual RETAIL charges-as the intermediate profit is saved to the purchaser.

Draft Paper, 68., 7s., 78. 9d., and 9s. per ream.
Brief Paper, 13s. 6d., 168., and 18s. 6d. per ream.
Foolscap Paper, 10s. 6d., 138. 6d., and 178, 6d. per ream.
Cream Laid Note, 3s., 4s., and 58. per ream.

Large Cream Laid Note, 48., 68., and 7s. 6d. per ream.
Large Blue Note, 3s., 4s., and 68, per ream.

Envelopes, Cream, Blue, or Buff. 2s. 9d., 38. 6d., and 4s. 6d. per 1000.
Blottings, Browns, Cartridges, Tapes, Piercers, Runners, &c.
Foolscap Official Envelopes, 1s. 6d. per 100, or 13s. 6d. per 1000.
Letter Copying Press (warranted), 25; Good Stand for ditto, with two
Drawers, 178.

Indenture Skins, Printed and Machine-ruled to hold twenty or thirty
Parchment, best Quality.
folios, 1s. 4d. each, or 15s. per dozen.
Seconds or Followers, Ruled. 1s. 3d. each, or 14s. per dozen.
Records or Memorials, Ruled, 5s. per dozen, or 22s. 6d. per roil.
Ledgers, Day-books, Cash-books, Letter or Minute-books, an immense
stock in various bindings.

An Illustrated Price List of Inkstands; Postage Scales; Writing-cases;
Despatch Boxes; Oak and Walnut Stationery Cabinets; and other
useful articles adapted for Library or Office, post-free.
с

[merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][subsumed][ocr errors][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small]
[blocks in formation]
[ocr errors][merged small]

, 28

Greenfield v. Edwards and Others.-(Mortgagor and mortgagee-Trustee-Covenants in mortgage deed -Action at law-Injunction)....

VICE-CHANCELLOR WOOD'S COURT.

55

By J. HOWARD, Barrister at Law. Bailey v. Birchall.—(Solicitor and client― CostsCharge on estate-23 & 24 Vict. c. 127-Set-off).. 57 The Singer Sewing Machine Manufacturing Company v. Wilson.-(Practice-Evidence-Time for crossexamination-Reg. Gen., Feb. 5, 1861)....

COURT OF QUEEN'S BENCA.

By C. W. LOVESY, Barrister at Law. Reg. v. Hall Dare. (Sewers rate — Landowner Occupier-Poor cute Deductions-6 & 7 Will. 4, c. 96 (Parochial Assessment Act), s. 1).. The Mercantile Marine Insurance Company v. Tytherington. (Marine insurance-Policy-Computation of time)

Reg. v. The Local Board of Health of the Borough of Godmanchester.—(Sewer-Drain- Local board of health-Public Health Act, 1848 (11 & 12 Vict. c.

49

Luff v. Lord.-(Trustee and cestui que trust-Purchase by trustee-Allegations of fraud)

50

COURT OF APPEAL IN CHANCERY. By C. MARETT, Barrister at Law.

63)

[blocks in formation]

THE

53

HE LAW MAGAZINE AND LAW REVIEW for FEBRUARY, being No. 36 of the United New Series, is this day published, price 5s., and contains-1. Observations on a Digest of Law, with reference to the Address of Sir James Wilde at York.2. The Preservation of the English Law.-3. Local Courts of Record-4. Proposal for Amending the Law affecting Juries and Jurymen.5. Presumptive Proof. The Case of Müller.-6. Smith on Real Property and Conveyancing.-7. Law Reports and Law Reporting.8. Court of Final Appeal in Ecclesiastical Causes.-9. General Average. -10. The Law Reforms of the coming Session.-Events of the Quarter; Notices, &c. London Butterworths, 7, Fleet-street, Her Majesty's Law Publishers.

KA

AIN'S SOLICITORS' BOOKKEEPING, Seventh Edition, price 6s., to be had of KAIN & SPARROW, Law and Mercantile Accountants, 69, Chancery-lane, W. C.; of WATERLOWS, London-wall, E. C.; and through all Booksellers.

ACCOUNT BOOKS (Priced List free).-"KAIN'S

SYSTEM is easily acquired; it shews at a glance the results of the business." To be had as above. Adopters, 1272. Account Books issued, 3041; to last year 1153 and 2715 respectively.

[blocks in formation]

COURT OF COMMON PLEAS.

By H. RUTHERFURD, Barrister at Law. Baker, App., Locke, Resp.-(Registratim in borough -Disqualification by non-payment of poor rateAssistant overseer signing a rate, effect of-2 Will. 4, c. 45, s. 27).. Flatcher v. Boodle.--(Borough registration of votersDisqualification by non-payment of proportion of poor's rate-17 Geo. 2, c. 38, s. 12 -2 § 3 Will. 4, c. 45, s. 27)......

BYTHEWOOD AND JARMAN'S CONVEYANCING.-
Vol. 8, Part 1.
Price 88. boards,

A

58

59

62

63

65

67

SELECTION of PRECEDENTS from MODERN MANUSCRIPT COLLECTIONS, and DRAFTS of ACTUAL PRACTICE; forming a System of Conveyancing. With Dissertations and Practical Notes. By THOMAS JARMAN, Esq., of the Middle Temple, Barrister at Law. The Third Edition. Vol. 8. By WHITLEY STOKES, Esq., of the Inner Temple, Barrister at Law. PART 1.-POWERS OF ATTORNEY.

UN

H. Sweet, 3, Chancery-lane, Fleet-street.

[NIVERSAL LIFE ASSURANCE SOCIETY, 1, King William street, London, E. C. Established 1834, with Branches at Calcutta, Madras, and Bombay.-Very economical Home and Colonial Rates for Civil and Military Lives. Division every Year of one-fifth of Profits. Premiums on all Participating Policies Six Years

in force reduced one-half for the Year ending May, 1865, so that 507.

only of each 1007. of premium falling due is charged. Total Assurances issued exceed 7,000,0007. sterling; Claims paid, 1,250,000.; Cash Bonuses to Assured, 565,000l., or an average annual return of 98. in the pound at twenty-five divisions of profit. Advances made on LifeInterests, and on Real and other Property in connexion with Assurances. FREDERICK HENDRIKS, Actuary and Secretary. ANNUITIES AND REVERSIONS. AW REVERSIONARY INTEREST SOCIETY. 68, CHANCERY-LANE, LONDON. CHAIRMAN Russell Gurney, Q.C., Recorder of London. DEPUTY CHAIRMAN-Sir W. J. Alexander, Bart., Q. C. Reversions and Life Interests purchased. Immediate and Deferred Annuities granted in exchange for Reversionary and Contingent In

LA

terests.

Loans may also be obtained on the security of Reversions. Annuities, Immediate, Deferred, and Contingent, and also Endowments, granted on favourable terms.

Prospectuses and Forms of Proposal, and all further information, may be had at the Office. C. B. CLABON, Sec.

COALS.-J. PERCIVAL & CO.'S, BEST ONLY,

DR.

screened, Cash Price 28s. per Ton.-HORSESHOE WHARF, UPPER THAMES-STREET. West-end Office, 64, New Bond-street. CURES OF COUGHS AND COLDS, BY R. LOCOCK'S PULMONIC WAFERS. - From Mr. WILCOX, 7, Prospect-row, Birmingham:-" For years I have recommended them, and never known them to fail." They give instant relief of asthma, consumption, coughs, and all disorders of the breath and lungs. Price 18. 1d., 28. 9d., and 48. 6d. per box. Sold by all Druggists.

THE JURIST.

LONDON, JANUARY 28, 1865.

Common Pleas held, that an assignée of an existing rent-charge did not acquire actual possession of it before he received payment. In Heelis's case, Mr. Joshua Williams, for the appellant, contended, that as the rent-charge was limited to his use, the Statute of Uses, 27 Hen. 8, c. 10, s. 1, gave him " the lawful seisin, estate, and possession of and in the same" rent; and he cited many authorities to shew that the statute passes the actual possession; among them, an anonymous case in Cro. Eliz. 46, or rather a note of the reporter, “that cestui que use at this day is immediately and actually seised and in possession of the land, so that he may have an assize or trespass before entry against any stranger who enters without title, and this by the words of the statute; and this was the opinion of divers justices." On the strength of these authorities, the Court decided in favour of the claim. "At common law," said Erle, C. J., "there would have been no actual possession till July; and there are two authorities for this. But this was not a conveyance at common law, but under the Statute of Uses. The stat. 27 Hen. 8, c. 10, s. 1, gives the cestui que use possession immediately on the execution of the deed creating the use. Now, the stat. 2 Will. 4, c. 45, by sect. 26, requires the claimant to be in actual possession. I think, however, that the Legislature intended the same meaning to the word 'possession' in the stat. Hen. 8, as it did to the words actual possession' in the 26th section of the Reform Act. Of course, any illusory act would have no operation, such as the payment of a penny for rent." [Why not? Such a payment would give the actual seisin of the rent at common law, and could not be more illusory than the merely technical juggle of limiting a use.] "The word 'possession' has always had a technical and perfectly well understood meaning among conveyancers; and we have the highest authority for giving great weight to the practice of conveyancers." According to the report in the Weekly Reporter, the Chief Justice remarked, that the mantle of some of the old conveyancers had descended on Mr. Williams, and the Court had had the benefit of it in the argument—a well-merited compliment—which, however, would have been more valuable if the Court had shewn a better appreciation of the learned conveyancer's argument, by exposing the fallacy that lurked in it. Mr. Williams made the best of a bad case, and obtained a judgment in his favour, but the decision was plainly erroneous. The conveyance in question was not a conveyance operating under the Statute of Uses, but a grant at common law, passing a legal seisin or title, but insufficient to pass the actual seisin or possession of the rent, which could only be obtained by the receipt of the rent, or of something in lieu of it. The words of the 1st section of the Statute of Uses are, that the person who has the "use, shall from thenceforth stand and be seised, deemed, and adjudged in lawful seisin, estate, and possession of and in the same honours, castles, manors, lands, rents, service, remainders, and hereditaments, with their appoint

ONE of the main evils of profuse reporting is the encouragement it affords to the arguing and deciding of cases by reference to authorities supposed to be in point, rather than by the light of established general principles. For illustration, we may refer to the case of Heelis, App., Blain, Resp., decided by the Court of Common Pleas (Erle, C. J., and Keating, J.) in November, 1864 (11 Jur., N. S., part 1, p. 18; 13 Weekly Rep. 262). The question arose upon a case stated by a revising barrister, by which it appeared that the appellant claimed to vote under the Reform Act, 2 Will. 4, c. 45, s. 26, as having been in "the actual possession" of a share of a certain rent-charge of 501. for six calendar months previous to the 31st July, 1864. The rent-charge was originally created by a deed of the 10th June, 1839, and made payable at Midsummer and Christmas, and had been paid half-yearly since that time. By indenture, dated the 29th January, 1864, Stephen Heelis, in whom the rent-charge was vested, granted it to John Heelis and his heirs, to the use of the five sons of the said Stephen Heelis, their heirs and assigns for ever, as tenants in common. The first half-yearly payment which fell due after the transfer, was paid in July, 1864. It was objected, that the appellant, who was one of the five cestuis que use, did not obtain actual possession of his share until the payment in July; and the case of Murray and Another, Apps., Thorniley, Resp. (2 C. B. 217; 10 Jur. 270) was relied on. In that case, a claim to be registered in respect of the possession of a rentcharge for six months previous to the last day of July, 1845, was rested on a deed dated the 25th January, 1845, whereby a rent charge of 61. 3s. (not previously existing) was granted to the appellants and their heirs, to be paid on the 1st January in every year, the first payment to be made on the 1st January then next ensuing. The argument against the qualification proceeded on the well-known rule, that there is no actual seisin of a rent-charge at the common law until the owner has received some payment on account of the rent; and this, whether he claims under a grant or devise of a rent newly created, or a grant or devise of a rent previously existing. The Court held, that the words "actual possession," in the Reform Act, meant "a possession in fact, as contradistinguished from a possession in law; and that, as the possession in fact of a rent-charge must be the actual manual receipt of the rent itself, or some part of it, or of something in lieu of it, so there could be no such possession in fact in that case, where the first payment of the rent did not become due until after the expiration of the month of July, and where nothing whatever took place but the mere execution of the deed;" and they referred to the authorities collected in Com. Dig., tit. "Seisin,” (C.) and (D.), establishing the distinction between a seisin in law and a seisin in fact of a rent-charge. In Hayden, App., Overseers of Twerton, Resp. (4 C. B. 1), the Court of

* Smith v. Jersey (2 Br. & B. 599).

ments, to all intents, constructions, and purposes in the law, of and in such like estates as they had or shall have in use, trust, or confidence of or in the same, and that the estate, title, right, and possession that was in such person or persons that were or hereafter shall be seised of any lands, tenements, or hereditaments, to the use, confidence, or trust of any such person or persons, or of any body politic, be from thenceforth clearly deemed and adjudged to be in him or them that have, or hereafter shall have, such use, confidence, or trust after such quality, manner, form, and condition as they had before in or to the use, confidence, or trust that was in them." Nothing can be plainer from these words, than that the estate and possession which are transferred to the cestui que use are the estate and possession, or part of the estate and possession, which are in the grantee to use, and cannot exceed or be more absolute or consummate than such estate

28

A further moral to be deduced from the case is, that the old learning as to seisin and possession and uses, having done its work, is now obsolete, and should be abolished, as fines and recoveries have been abolished; provided that the task be undertaken by some one fully enveloped in the mantle of the late Mr. Brodie. It is the fashion to abuse the practice of conveyancing as being founded on the abstruse learning of uses. Theoretically, that is so, although the practice at the present day is simple enough, and none of the evils that the laity are taught to charge on the Statute of Uses are fairly attributable to it. But still the old learning crops up occasionally, and never to any good purpose.

Review.

The Notanda Digest, with Synoptical Index of the Decicisions in Law, Equity, Bankruptcy, Admiralty, Divorce, and Probate Cases. By TENISON EDWARDS, Esq. of the Inner Temple, Barrister-at-Law. From December, 1862, to December, 1864. 8vo., pp. 151.

[Day.]

and possession. "The matter and substance of the estate of cestui que use is the estate of the feoffee, and more he cannot have." (Bac. Uses, 47). "If the conusee of a fine, before any attornment, by deed indented and inrolled, bargaineth and selleth the signiorie to another, the bargainee shall not distrain, be- Ir is now nearly two years since Mr. Edwards comcause the bargainor could not distrain, et sic de simi- menced the publication of his very useful Notanda. libus, for nemo potest plus juris ad alium transferre Great praise is due to him for his enterprise in the quàm ipsi habet." (Co. Litt. 309. b.) Sir Moyle commencement of an undertaking which, we believe, Finch's case (6 Rep. 68 a.) was not cited by Mr. Wil- for a long time attracted little notice from the Profession, and for the perseverance and industry with liams, although, as far as it goes, it is an authority in which he has carried it on, until (as we must infer from his favour. There it was held, that a fine levied by a its continuance to the present time) it has become a reversioner to the use of another than the conusee, successful speculation. For the sake of those who passed the estate so completely that cestui que use are still unacquainted with the work, we may reprint the author's explanation of his original plan:might avow for the rent, or have an action for waste, "The question is: How can the practitioner with without any attornment, because the Statute of Uses the greatest facility make himself acquainted with the passed the seisin immediately, and made it impossible latest decisions upon any given subject? And my that the conusee should have a quid juris clamat, &c. reply is: By looking, not through a dozen annual diBut the reasons, such as they were, on which that gests, but by looking to the standard text-books, such conclusion was founded, were held to be inapplicable as Sugden's Vendors and Purchasers, Williams on Exeto a conveyance by deed; so that a grant of a rever-sition with the topics treated of, and on the very page cutors, Jarman on Wills, &c.; and there, in juxtaposion to uses was imperfect without attornment, and where the author in his next edition would introduce was capable of being perfected by attornment to the modern decisions, to find clear and intelligible cestui que use. (Harwell v. Lucas, Moore, 99 a). See notes of such decisions as have been come to upon the Dixon v. Harrison, Vaugh. 51; and the conclusion of particular topic since the edition of the work. Or, if the judgment in Long v. Buckeridge (1 Str. 112). to turn to the section of that statute, and there to the question turn upon the construction of a statute, However it might have been in the case of a fine or a find like clear and intelligible notes of the decisions recovery, it is clear, equally on principle and on au- upon that particular section. I have explained my thority, that in that of a mere grant to uses the plan in answering the above question, and I have no actual seisin or possession does not pass under the fear of a contradiction from any practical man.” Statute of Uses, unless it is first in the grantee to in the authorised and unauthorised reports, and of the The work consists of short notes of cases reported uses. In the principal case John Heelis took by grant statutes as they are passed, with references to the text at common law a legal seisin of the rent, and he took books, leading cases, or statutes, in which they may nothing more than that seisin, and nothing more passed be noted up, either by copying or by actually cutting to the cestuis que use. The Court committed the mis- out each note and gumming it to the place referred to, take of confounding a conveyance to uses, transferring or by entering merely the number of the note, for the title by a common law assurance, with a bargain The number affixed to the last entry in Notanda for which purpose the notes are numbered consecutively. and sale or covenant to stand seised of an existing December, 1864, is 3214. rent by one already in the actual seisin and possession of the rent. Finding decisions to the effect, that the Statute of Uses transfers the actual possession, they looked no further, but jumped to the conclusion, that wherever the statute operates, the actual seisin passes. This would not have happened fifty years ago, when cases were the servants, not the masters, of principles.

Not content with the use of the work as an aid to noting up, Mr. Edwards now publishes with each number an index to that number, and to all those which have preceded it, so that there is never any more than one index for reference. This, he suggests, may serve as a partial index to all the text books referred to in the Notanda, and also be a digest, revised and renewed at frequent intervals, to all the cases from the time of

« PreviousContinue »