Law Library

COPYRIGHT, 1910

BY

WEST PUBLISHING COMPANY

(125 S.W.)

SOUTHWESTERN REPORTER, VOLUME 125

c.3

JUDGES

OF THE

COURTS REPORTED DURING THE PERIOD

COVERED BY THIS VOLUME

ARKANSAS-Supreme Court.
EDGAR A. McCULLOCH, CHIEF JUSTICE.

ASSOCIATE JUSTICES.
BURRILL B. BATTLE

JESSE C. HART.
CARROLL D. WOOD.

SAMUEL FRACENTIIAL.

KENTUCKY-Court of Appeals.
T. J. NUNN, CHIEF JUSTICE.

ASSOCIATE JUSTICES.
HENRY S. BARKER.

JOHN D. CARROLL.
JOHN M. LASSING.

ED. C. O'REAR.
J. P. HOBSON.

W. E. SETTLE.

COMMISSIONER OF APPEALS.
WILLIAM ROGERS CLAY.

MISSOURI—Supreme Court.
LEROY B. VALLIANT, CHIEF JUSTICE.

Division No. 1.
HENRY LAMM, PRESIDING JUDGE.

ASSOCIATE JUDGES.
WALLER W. GRAVES.

ARCHELAUS M. WOODSON.
LEROY B. VALLIANT.

Dizision No. 2.

JAMES B. GANTT, PRESIDING JUDGE.

ASSOCIATE JUDGES.
GAVON D. BURGESS.

JAMES D. FOX.

The Kansas City Court of Appeals.
E. J. BROADDUS, PRESIDING JUDGE.

ASSOCIATE JUDGES.
JAMES ELLISON.

J. M. JOHNSON.

The St. Louis Court of Appeals.
GEORGE D. REYNOLDS, PRESIDING JUDGE.

ASSOCIATE JUDGES.
RICHARD L. GOODE.

ALPERT D. NORTONI,

The Springfield Court of Appeals.
J. P. NIXON, PRESIDING JUDGE.

ASSOCIATE JUDGES.
ARGUS COX.

HOWARD GRAY.

TENNESSEE-Supreme Court.

W. D. BEARD, CHIEF JUSTICE.

ASSOCIATE JUSTICES. W. K. MCALISTER.

M. M. NEIL, JOHN K. SHIELDS.

BENNETT D. BELL

1

1 Resigned January 1, 1910.

* Deceased. • Appointed January 1, 1910.

• Appointed to succeed H. C. Fisher, deceased. • Appointed to succeed W. M. Key.

CASES REPORTED.

Page

Page A. B. Frank Co., Martin v. (Tex. Civ. App.) 938 Big Sandy & C. R. Co., Hurley v. (Ky.)... 302 Adams, American Tobacco Co. v. (Ky.)... 1067 Bilby v. Hancock (Tex. Civ. App.). 370 Adams v. State (Ark.).... .1199 Bilby v. Rodgers (Tex. Civ. App.).

616 Etna Ins. Co. v. Hawkins (Tex.). 313 Blakley v. Hanberry (Ky.)...

703 Affleck, Mortimore v. (Tex. Civ. App.). 51 Blanding, Coats v. (Tex. Civ. App.). 627 Agee, State v. (Mo.)... 466 Blanchette v. State (Tex. Cr. App.).

26 Aldridge, Cleveland v. (Ark.).

.1016 Blanks, Missouri, K. & T. R. Co. of Texas Alexander, Hill v. (Tex. Civ. App.). 333 v. (Tex.)...

312 Alexander, Wade v. (Mo.).. ...1108 Block, Bailey v. (Tex. Civ. App.).

955 Allen v. Edrington (Tex. Civ. App.). ..... 362 Bloomfield, Home Ins. Co. of New York v. American Car & Foundry Co., Bowman v.

(Mo. App.)..

.1193 (Mo.) . 1120 Blumenthal, State v. (Mo. App.).

.1188 American Credit Indemnity Co. of New Blum, Pittsburg, C., C. & St. L. R. Co. v. York v. Hecht & Co. (Ky.). .

697
(Ky.)

300 American Tobacco Co. v. Adams (Ky.)...1067 Board of Councilmen of Town of NicholasAnderson v. Electric Park Amusement Co.

ville, Star Mill. Co. v. (Ky.).

. 1051 (No. App.)...

..1196 Board of Council of City of Danville, BurAnderson, St. Louis Southwestern R. Co. dette v. (Ky.)...

275 of Texas v. (Tex. Civ. App.)..

628 Board of Directors St. Francis Levee DisArkansas Stave Co. v. State (Ark.) .1001 trict v. Fleming (Ark.)...

132 Armstrong, Louisville, H. & St. L. R. Co.

Board of Directors of St. Francis Levee V. (Ky.).. 276 Dist. v. Fleming (Ark.).

659 Arnett v. Commonwealth (Ky.). 700 Bonner v. State (Tex. Cr. App.).

22 Arnett v. Williams (Mo.).

.1154 Bothell v. Fletcher & Stobaugh (Ark.)... 615 Arthur Cotton Co. v. Willis (Tex. Civ. Bowden v. Crawford (Tex.). App.)

584 Bowman v. American Car & Foundry Co. Atzinson Imp. Co., Sweeden v. (Ark.). 439

(Mo.)

.1120 Austin v. Jackson Trust & Savings Bank

Bradfield, Sapp v. (Ky.)...

721 (Tex. Cir. App.).... 936 Brannock v. Magoon (Mo. App.).

53.5

Bray, Taney County Bank v. (Mo. App.).. 235 Badger Lumber Co. v. Staley (Mo. App.) 779 Brewer v. State (Ark.).

127 Badu v. Satterwhite (Tex. Civ. App.)..... 929 Brier v. State Exch. Bank of Macon (Mo.) 469 Bailey v. Block (Tex. Civ. App.).

955 Brin, Shrimpton Mfg. Co. v. (Tex. Civ.

620 Bailey, Dorroh y. (Tex. Civ. App.).

App.)

942 Baldwin v. San Antonio (Tex. Civ. App.).. 596 Broadway Coal Jin. Co. v. Smith (Ky.).. 157 Ball, Chesapeake & O. R. Co. v. (Ky.). 246 Brown v. Cole (Mo. App.).

537 Bail, Ramseaur v. (Tex. Civ. App.). 590 Brown v. Lovelace (Ky.)..

113 Bangs, Western Union Tel. Co. v. (Ark.)..1012 Brown v. Scruggs (Mo. App.).

5:37 Bank of Mountain View, Padgett v. (Mo.

Brown v. Spradlin (Kv.).

150 App.)

219 Brown v. Springfield Traction Co. (Mo. Bank of Ozark v. Hanks (Mo. App.). 221 App.)

236

915 Bank of Springdale, Pritchard v. (Ark.)...1199 Brown v. State (Tex. Cr. App.). Bank of Waldron v. Euper (Ark.).

.1022 Bryan, Harris Millinery Co. v. (Tex. Civ. Barber Asphalt Pav. Co. v. Tomlinson App.)

999 (Mo. App.)..

.1175 Bryan, Houston & T. C. R. Co. v. (Tex. Barnard, Glasscock v. (Tex. Civ. App.)... 615

Civ. App.).

82 Barnes v. State (Tex. Cr. App.).. 39 Bryan v. Yungblut (Kv.).

201 Barry County v. Sherman (Mo. Anp.). 781 Buch, Texas & N. 0. R. Co. v. (Tex. Civ. Bartels, Johnson County Sav. Bank v.

App.)

316 (Tes. Civ. App.). ., 57 Bullock v. Menninger (Ky.).

2.30; Bartlett, State ex rel. Black v. (Mo. App.) 839 Bunker, Chotard v. (Ark.).

.1199 Barton v. Haltom (Ark.).

418
Burdette v. Board of Council of City of

275 Baskett v. Ohio Valley Banking & Trust

Danville (Ky.). Co. (Ky.). .1066 Burke v. State (Tex. Cr. App.).

8 Baum v. McAfee (Tex. Civ. App.)..

984 Burk's Springs Distilling Co., CommonBaxter, Wettlaufer v. (Ky.).

741
wealth v. (Ky.)....

306 Beam's Adm'r, Quigley v. (Ky.)..... 727 Burns v. State (Tex. Cr. App.).

901 Bear, Webster v. (Mo. App.).. 815 Burrell v. State (Tex. Cr. App.).

570) Beasley v. State (Tex. Cr. App.). 565 Bush v. Fitzgeralds (Ky.)...

716 Berton, Hartford Fire Ins. Co. v. (Tex.)... 883 Byrd v. Central Kentucky Traction Co. Bell v. State (Ark.).

..1020
(Ky.)

174 Belmont v. Jones' House Furnishing Co.

Byrne, City of Kirkwood v. (Mo. App.).... 810

651 V. Missouri & Kansas Tel. Co. Cache Valley Lumber Co. y. Culver Co. (Mo. App.).. 533 (Ark.)

430 Bergmann, Harrison v. (Tex. Civ. App.). 359 Cairo Brewing Co. v. Hogg (Mo. App.).. 831 Berman v. Shelby (Ark.). 124 Caldwell, Ex parte_(Tex. Cr. App.).

2,3 Berry v. State (Tex. Cr. App.). 580 Caldwell & Drake, Jobe v. (Ark.).

423 Best v. State (Tex. Cr. App.). 909 Callaway, Hall v. (Ark.).

.1015 Berens, Collinsworth V. (Ky.).

.1060 Cameron State Bank, Uher v. (Tex. Civ. Rever v. Home Ins. Co. of New York (Mo. App.)

321 .1184 | Campbell v. Hoosier Stare & Lumber Co. Bibb, Western Union Tel. Co. v. (Ky.).... 257 (Mo. App.)...

845

(Ark.) Bentley

App.)

724

Page

Pago Campbell v. State (Tex, Cr. App.).... 893 Commonwealth v. Burk's Springs Distilling Cannedy v. State (Tex. Cr. App.). 31 Co. (Ky.)..

306 Cardwell v. Conner (Mo. App.).

234 Commonwealth, Combast v. (Ky.). ..1092 Carr, Gupton v. (Mo. App.).. 849 Commonwealth v. Goulet (Ky.).

.1083 Carter-Kelly Lumber Co., Havard v. (Tex. Commonwealth v. Hodges (Ky.).

689 Civ. App.)... 928 Commonwealth, Kammerer v. (Ky.).

723 Cary v. Schmeltz (Mo. App.).

532 Commonwealth v. Louisville Traction Co. Case Threshing Mach. Co. v. Combs (Ky.) 289 (Ky.)

711 Case Threshing Mach. Co. v. Patterson Commonwealth, Oldham v. (Ky.).

242 (Ky.)

287 Commonwealth v. Richardson (Ky.). 147 Catlin v. United States Fidelity & Guaran- Commonwealth, Stratman v. (Ky.). .1094 ty Co. (Ky.). 297 | Conner, Cardwell v. (Mo. App.).

231 Central City Light & Power Co., Lancas- Continental Casualty Co. v. Deeg (Tex. Civ. ter's Adm'x v. (Ky.)... 739 App.)

333 Central Kentucky Traction Co., Byrd v. Coquillard Wagon Works v. Melton (Ky.) 291 (Ky.) 174 Court, State v. (Mo.).

451 Charles Moore & Co., Mutual Mfg. Co. v. Cox, Frazier v. (Ky.).

148 (Ky.) 267 Cox y. Smith (Ark.)..

437 Chastain v. Missouri, K. & T. R. Co. (Mo.)1009 Cox's" Adm'r, Louisville & A. R. Co. v. Cheatham v. State (Tex. Cr. App.). 56.) (Ky.)

1056 Chenault, Jeffries v. (Ky.). 1052 Coy v. Humphreys (Mo. App.).

877 Chesapeake & O. R. Co. v. Ball (Kv.). 246 Coy v. Landers (Mo. App.).

789 Chesapeake & O. R. Co., Young's Adm'r v. Craddock & Co. v. Wells Fargo Co. Ex(Ky.) 241 press (Tex. Civ. App.).

5.9 Chicago Great Western R. Co., Gibson v. Crawford, Bowden v. (Tex.).

5 (Mo.)

453 Crenshaw, Western Union Tel. Co. v. Chicago, R. I. & P. R. Co. v. Yancy (Ark.)1199 (Ark.)

420 Childers, Gayheart v. (Ky.)..

. 1085 Crowder v. Fordyce Lumber Co. (Ark.).. 417 Chilton v. Louisville Property Co. (Ky.). . 732 Orownover. Tatum v. (Ark.).

.1010 Chotard v. Bunker (Ark.).

.1199 Crull, Williams Land Co. v. (Tex. Civ. Citizens' Bank of Laredo v. Lowder (Mo. App.)

339 App.) .1180 Crume, McClure v. (Ky.).

164 Citizens' R. Co. v. Robertson (Tex. Civ. Culver Co., Cache Valley Lumber Co. v. App.) 343 (Ark.)

430 City of Ashland. Young v. (Ky.).

737 Cumberland Telephone & Telegraph Co., City of Carterville, Wonner v. (Mo. App.) 861 Wight v. (Ky.).

718 City of Fayetteville, Walker v. (Ark.).. 412 Cuneo v. Zilker (Tex. Civ. App.).

91 City of Houston, Pullman v. \(Tex. Civ. Currier, State v. (Mo.)..

461 App.) 69 Curtis v. Sexton (Mo. App.).

806 City of Kirkwood v. Byrne (Mo. App.). 810 C. W. Georgs Mfg. Co., Dowlen v. (Tex. City of Louisville, Treasy v. (Ky.).

706
Civ. App.).

931 City of Morehead, Watson v. (Ky.).... City of Oakdale, 'Lenox Land Co. v. (Ky.) 1089 Damron v. State (Tex. Cr. App.).

396 City of Oakdale, New Louisville Jockey Club v. (Ky.)....

1089
Daniel v. State (Tex. Cr. App.).

37 Daniels v. State (Tex. Cr. App.).

398 City of St. Louis v. Glum (Mo.).

.1128
Dannahower, State v. (Mo. App.).

518 City of St. Louis, Peters v. (Mo.). .1134 City of St. Louis v. Tielkemeyer (Mo.).:::1123 Davidson v. I. M. Davidson Real Estate &

Investment Co. (Mo.).

.1113 City of Salem ex rel. Roney v. Young (Mo.

Davidson v. Ryle (Tex.).

881 App.)

857

Davidson Real Estate & Investment Co., City of San Antonio, Baldwin v. (Tex. Civ.

Davidson v. (Mo.)...

..1143 App.) 596

989 City of Springfield, Lewis v. (Mo. App.).: 824 Dean, Openshaw y. (Tex. Civ. App.). C. J. Gerlach & Bro., Ziegler v. (Tex. Civ.

Deeg, Continental Casualty Co. v. (Tex. 80

Civ. App.). App.)

3.53 Clancy, State v. (Mo.).

351 458 Denny, Scaling v. (Tex. Civ. App.).

14.5 Clark, International & G. N. R. Co. v.

Deweese v. Maxwell (Ky.). (Tex. Civ. App.)..

959

Dierks Lumber & Coal Co., Mason v. (Ark.) 656 Clark v. State (Tex. Cr. App.).

12

Dockery v. Maple (Tex. Civ. App.)..... 631 Clark, Ware v. Tex, Civ. App.).

618
Dodge v. Thomason (Ark.).

648 Clayborn, Young Bros, & Co. v. (Ky.). 712

Dorham v. State (Tex. Cr. App.).

397 Clayes, Kessler v. (Mo. App.).

799

Dorrance & Co. v. International & G. N. Clayton v. Mallory (Ky.)... 262

561

R. Co. (Tex.)..
Clemmer v. Price (Tex, Civ. App.)

604
Dorrohv. Bailey (Tex. Civ. App.)

620 Cleveland v. Aldridge (Ark.).

1016
Dowell v. Dowell's Adm'r (Ky.).

283 Clinkenbeard, State v. (Mo. App.).

827
Dowell's Adm'r, Dowell v. (Ky.).

2S3 Coats v. Blanding (Tex. Civ. App.). 627

Dowlen v. C. W. Georgs Mfg. Co. (Tex. Cobb, Western Union Tel. Co. v. (Tex.)... 311

Civ. App.)....

931 Cobb v. Works (Tex. Civ. App.).

349 Driscoll, Rogers v. (Tex. Civ. App.). 599 Coffey, Tiffany v. (Mo. App.).

.1178 Dunham v. Orange Lumber Co. (Tex. Civ. Cole, Brown v. (Mo. App.).

App.)

89 Cole, Wallace v. (Ky.).

261 Coleman, R. B. Godley Lumber Co. v. (Tex. Earll, State v. (Mo.)..

467 Civ. App.)... 630 Eastham v. Gibbs (Tex. Civ. App.).

372 Collier, Remmel v. (Ark.).

422 Eckman, Louisville & N. R. Co. v. (Ky.).. 729 Collins v. State (Ark.).

017 Edrington, Allen v. (Tex. Cir. App.)...... 362 Collins, State v. (Mo.). 465 Edwards v. State (Tex. Cr. App.)..

89 Collins, State v. (Tex. Civ. App.).

57 Elder & Sons, Strong v. (Tex. Civ. App.).. 374 Collinsworth v. Bevens (Ky.).

1060 Electric Park Amusement Co., Anderson v. Columbia Securities Co., First Nat. Bank (Mo. App.)...

.11.06 v. (Mo. App.)...

.1194 Elliott, National Casket Co. v. (Ky.). 279 Combast v. Commonwealth (Ky.). .1092 | Elliott v. State (Tex. Cr. App.)..

508 Combs, Ex parte (Ark.)... 1199 | Ellis v. State (Tex. Cr. App.).

57. Combs, J. I. Case Threshing Mach, Co. v. Ellis v. State (Tex. Cr. App.)

892 (Ky.)

289 El Paso & S. W. R. Co. v. Welter (Tex.

537