OF CASES ARGUED AND DETERMINED IN THE SUPREME COURT OF JUDICATURE OF THE STATE OF INDIANA, WITH TABLES OF THE CASES REPORTED AND CASES CITED AND AN INDEX. BY JOHN L. GRIFFITHS, OFFICIAL REPORTER. VOL. 128, CONTAINING CASES DECIDED AT THE NOVEMBER TERM, CASES DECIDED AT THE MAY TERM, 1891. INDIANAPOLIS: B 15310 BY JOHN L. GRIFFITHS, PRINTED AND BOUND BY ELECTROTYPED BY INDIANAPOLIS ELECTROTYPE CARLON & HOLLENBECK, MUDIANAPOLIS. FOUNDRY. 192 TABLE OF THE CASES REPORTED IN THIS VOLUME. Aiken, Grigsby v. .591 | Chicago and Indiana Coal R. W. Anderson v. Anderson, 254 Co. v. Hunter.. 213 Aspy, Steele v. 367 Cincinnati Steam Heating Co., Austin v. Davis. 472 Board of Commissioners of Gibson Co. v .240 Barnes v. Sammons. .596 Citizens' Ins. Co. v. Hoffman. .370 Barrett v. Sear. .261 Citizens' Street R. R. Co.,Western Bassett, Ellis v 118 Paving and Supply Co. v. .525 Belt Railroad and Stockyard Citizens' Street R. W. Co. v. RobCo., Mann v.. 138 bins. 419 Bence, Huffmond v 131 City of Frankfort v. State, ex rel. Berry v. Louisville, Evansville Ross .438 and St. Louis R. R. Co.. .484 City of Lawrenceburgh, Small v.231 Bingham v. Walk, 164 Cook v. McNaughton.. 410 Blue Ridge Marble Co. v. Duffy. 79 Cox, Shattuck v. 293 Board of Commissioners of Foun- Craig, Montgomery v 48 tain Co. v. Board of Commis- Cravens, Orr v .359 sioners of Warren Co........295 Crowder v. Town of Sullivan. .486 Board of Commissioners of Gib. Crum v. Meeks. .360 son Co. v. Cincinnati Steam Culbertson, Parker v 319 Heating Co... .240 Cummings v. Martin. 20 Board of Commissioners of Rush Custer, Michigan Mutual Life Co., Gilson v 65 Ins. Co. v. 25 Board of Commissioners of Tip. ton Co., Woods v .289 Darnell, Sumner v 38 Board of Commissioners of War- Davis, Austin v. 472 ren Co., Board of Commission- Davis v. Fasig .271 ers of Fountain Co. v... .295 Davis v. Ladoga Creamery Co., Bogard, State, ex rel. Reese, v 480 by Talbut, Receiver. 222 Boicourt, Lane v. 420 Dick v. Mullins. 365 Bowen v. Stewart. .507 Dickey, English v. 174 Boyce, Neely v. 1 Dickey v. Shirk. 278 Brazil Block Coal Co., Hyland v.335 Duffy, Blue Ridge Marble Co. v. 79 Brighton v. White.. .320 Drownlee, Cashman v .266 Eller v. Evans... 156 Brunker, Terre Haute and In- Ellis v. Bassett. 118 dianapolis R. R. Co. v.... .542 English v. Dickey 174 Budd v. Reidelbach. .145 Evans, Eller v. 1513 Burch, Nichols, Shepard & Co.v.324 Evansville and Richmond R. R. Co. v. Swift.. 34 Cadwallader v. Louisville, New Albany and Chicago R. W. Co.518 Falley v. Gribling. :110 Cashman v. Brownlee. ..266 Fasig, Davis v. 271 Chaplin v. Sullivan. 50 | Fenstamaker, flewett v. 315 sons 77 First Nat'l Bank of Peru v. Par- Talbut, Receiver, Davis v.. .147 | La Matt v. State, ex rel. Lucas., 123 Florer v. Sherwood. 495. Lane v. Boicourt. .420 Fontanet Co-Operative Mining Lawrenceburgh, City of, Small v. 231 Ass'n, Shull v. .331 Leming v: Sale.. 317 Frankfort, City of, v. State, ex Louisville, Evansville and St. rel. Ross... 438 Louis R. R. Co., Berry v. .484 Franklin, Mills v 444 Louisville, New Albany and ChiFreedom, Town of, v. Norris....377 cago R. W. Co., Cadwallader v.518 Louisville, New Albany and ChiGalbraith, State, ex rel. Harri- cago R. W. Co. v. Hendricks..462 son, v.. .501 Louisville, New Albany and ChiGammon Theological Seminary cago R. W. Co., Miller v. 97 v. Robbins. 85 | Louisville, New Albany and ChiGeisendortl, McDonald v. .153 cago R. W. Co. v. Wolfe. .347 Gilson v. Board of Commissioners Loy v. Loy 150 of Rush Co... 65 Luzader v. Richmond. ..344 Goff v. McGee.. .394 Gribling, Falley v .110 Mann v. Belt Railroad and Stock Grigsby v. Aiken .591 .138 Griswold v. Ward. .389 Mansfield v. Shipp 55 Martin, Cummings v. 20 Hardy, Mills v. 311 McClatchey, Ries v. .125 Hartmetz, Hormann v. 353 | McCollum v. Uhl.. .304 Harvey, Hoffman v.. 600 McCumber, Montgomery v. 374 Hastings, Horton v. 103 McDonaldóv. Geisendorff. .153 Hawkins v. Taylor. .431 McGee, Goff v. 394 Hedrick v. Hledrick. :522 McHenry v. Knickerbacker. Hendricks, Louisville, New Al- McNamee v. Rauck. 59 bany and Chicago R. W. Co. v.462 McNaughton, Cook v. .410 Hewett v. Fenstamaker. 315 Meeks, Crum v. .360 Hoffman, Citizens' Ins. Co. v. 370 | Merrill v. Shirk. .503 Hoffman v. Harvey. 600 Messick v. Midland R. W. Co.. 81 Hoffman, Indiana Ins. Co. v. 250 Michigan, Cummings y. 20 Hormann v. Hartmetz .353 Michigan Mutual Life Ins. Co. v. Horton v. Hastings. 103 25 Huffmond v. Bence. 131 Midland R. W. Co., Messick v. 81 Hughes v. Willson .. .491 Miller v. Louisville, New Albany Hunter, Chicago and Indiana and Chicago R. W. Co.. 97 Coal R. W. Co. v. .213 Mills v. Franklin. 444 Hyland v. Brazil Block Coal Co.335 Mills v. Hardy. .311 Montgomery y. Craig. 48 Indiana Ins. Co. v. Hoffman .250 Montgomery v. McCumber. .374 Indiana Natural Gas and Oil Co., Mullins, Dick v. .365 Jamieson v .555 Ingerman v. State,ex rel. Conroy. 225 Neely v. 1 Newlon v. Tvner. 466 Jackson, Plank v 424 258 Jamieson y. Indiana Natural Gas and Oil Co.... 555 Nichols, Shepard & Co. v. Burch 324 Johnson v. Johnson. Norris, Town of Freedom v.....377 93 Johnson, Spidell v. Johnston v. State, ex rel. Sefton. 16 Ohio and Mississippi R. W. Co. Joslyn v. State.. 160 197 Judson, Romaine v. .403 Orr v. Cravens. 359 Orr v. Owens. 229 Kiser, Newman v. 258 Osborne v. State, ex rel. Michaels. 129 Knickerbacker, McHenry v. 77 | Owens, Orr v. .229 Ladoga Creamery Company, by Parker v. Culbertson.. .319 235 fort v. Co. v.. Parsons, First Nat'l Bank of State, ex rel. Conroy, Ingerman v.225 Peru y. 147 State, ex rel. Harrison, v. GalParsons y. Pierson. .479 braith .. 501 Pearcy, Ohio and Mississippi R. State, ex rel. Hughes, Wills v..359 W. Co. V.. 197 State, ex rel. Lucas, La Mati v..123 Pierson, Parsons y 479 State, ex rel. Michaels, Osborne v.129 Plank v. Jackson. 424 State, ex rel. Powers, Robinson v.397 Purvis, Tarkington v .182 State, ex rel. Reese, v. Bogard .. .480 State, ex rel. Ross, City of FrankQuick, Reynolds v. 316 .438 State, ex rel. Sefton, Johnston v. 16 Rauck, McNamee v. 59 Steele v. Aspy .367 Reese, Scruggs v. .399 Stetler, Scott v. .385 Reidelbach, Budd v. .145 Stewart, Bowen v .507 Reynolds v. Quick. 316 Sullivan, Chaplin v. 50 Rhodes v. State. .189 Sullivan, Town of, Crowder v. .486 Richmond, Luzader v. .344 Sumner v. Darnell.. 38 Ries v. McClatchey. 125 Swift, Evansville and Richmond Ritter, Sedwick v. 209 R. R. Co. v. 34 Robbins, Citizens' Street R. W. 449 Tarkington v. Purvis. 182 Robbins, Gammon Theological Taylor, Hawkins y 431 Seminary v. 85 Terre Haute and Indianapolis R. Robinson v. State, ex rel Powers. 397 R. Co. v. Brunker. 542 Romaine v. Judson 403 Terre Haute and Logansport R. R. Co. v. Soice 105 Sale, Leming v. 317 | Town of Freedom y. Norris. 377 Sammons, Barnes v 596 Town of Sullivan, Crowder v 486 Scott v. Stetler. 385 Tyner, Newlon v. .466 Scruggs v. Reese. 399 Sear, Barrett v. 261 Sedwick v. Ritter. Uhl, McCollum v. 304 209 Shattuck v. Cox. 293 Sherwood, Florer v. 495 Vaughan v. State.. 14 Shipp, Mansfield v. 55 Shirk, Dickey v. 278 Walk, Bingham v 164 Shirk, Merrill v .503 Ward, Griswold v. 389 Shull v. Fontanet Co-Operative Western Paving and Supply Co. Mining Ass'n.. 331 v. Citizens' Street R. R. Co....525 Small v. City of Lawrenceburgh.231 / White, Brighton v. 320 Soice, Terre Haute and Logans- Wills v. State, ex rel. Hughes. . .359 port R. R. Co. v. ... 105 Willson, Hughes v. 491 Spidell v. Johnson .235 Wolfe, Louisville, New Albany State, Joslyn v. 160 and Chicago R. W. Co. v.. 347 State, Rhodes v. .189 Woods v. Board of CommissionState, Vaughan v. 14 ers of Tipton Co. 289 |